Comments on: Review of Dr Siegal’s Cookie Diet http://www.eateverythree.com/2008/09/review-of-dr-siegals-cookie-diet/ Eat Healthy & Eat Often Tue, 07 Sep 2010 11:08:40 -0500 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8 hourly 1 By: Cookies Are One Weight Loss Expert’s Answer, Dr Seigal’s Weight Loss Cookie Diet | FINALLY, A THINNER YOU http://www.eateverythree.com/2008/09/review-of-dr-siegals-cookie-diet/comment-page-1/#comment-343 Cookies Are One Weight Loss Expert’s Answer, Dr Seigal’s Weight Loss Cookie Diet | FINALLY, A THINNER YOU Mon, 22 Dec 2008 13:18:34 +0000 http://www.eateverythree.com/?p=185#comment-343 [...] Review of Dr Siegal’s Cookie Diet [...] [...] Review of Dr Siegal’s Cookie Diet [...]

]]> By: James Lemoine II http://www.eateverythree.com/2008/09/review-of-dr-siegals-cookie-diet/comment-page-1/#comment-189 James Lemoine II Wed, 24 Sep 2008 15:19:09 +0000 http://www.eateverythree.com/?p=185#comment-189 Thanks for commenting Dr. Siegal. My readers will appreciate your comments. I believe one can provide a high-level review of the Cookie Diet fundamentals without having tried it out. In the context of a blog article, I supplied a link that described some of the problems to the metabolism a low calorie diet can cause. I did not need to explain it myself. Men have substantially higher calorie requirements than women. It's a fact, not my opinion. It's my opinion that evey person has a unique set of calorie requirements based on their specific lifestyle. Suggesting that all people (both men and women, young and old), can SUCCESSFULLY lose weight (and keep it off) on the same calorie requirements is outrageous to me. Again that is my opinion. There are other articles on the site to explain my point of view. I doubt you have personally examined 500,000 people and verified their lost weight did not return once they stopped using the Cookie Diet. I agree your company is doing something right, and people are losing weight. My point is that most of them will gain the weight back when they get tired of eating one meal a day. The fact you are a medical doctor (osteopathy) does not make your diet safe or appropriate. Even of you don't agree, I'm sure you would agree there are doctors around that would dispute 800 calories can be sustained for any length of time. We'll leave it to the audience to decide for themselves. There are plenty of links to the Cookie Diet site in the article. ;-) Thanks for commenting Dr. Siegal. My readers will appreciate your comments.

I believe one can provide a high-level review of the Cookie Diet fundamentals without having tried it out.

In the context of a blog article, I supplied a link that described some of the problems to the metabolism a low calorie diet can cause. I did not need to explain it myself.

Men have substantially higher calorie requirements than women. It’s a fact, not my opinion.

It’s my opinion that evey person has a unique set of calorie requirements based on their specific lifestyle. Suggesting that all people (both men and women, young and old), can SUCCESSFULLY lose weight (and keep it off) on the same calorie requirements is outrageous to me. Again that is my opinion. There are other articles on the site to explain my point of view.

I doubt you have personally examined 500,000 people and verified their lost weight did not return once they stopped using the Cookie Diet.

I agree your company is doing something right, and people are losing weight. My point is that most of them will gain the weight back when they get tired of eating one meal a day.

The fact you are a medical doctor (osteopathy) does not make your diet safe or appropriate. Even of you don’t agree, I’m sure you would agree there are doctors around that would dispute 800 calories can be sustained for any length of time.

We’ll leave it to the audience to decide for themselves. There are plenty of links to the Cookie Diet site in the article. ;-)

]]> By: Sanford Siegal, D.O., M.D. http://www.eateverythree.com/2008/09/review-of-dr-siegals-cookie-diet/comment-page-1/#comment-188 Sanford Siegal, D.O., M.D. Tue, 23 Sep 2008 18:07:43 +0000 http://www.eateverythree.com/?p=185#comment-188 Thank you for taking the time to blog about Dr. Siegal's COOKIE DIET, James. While I appreciate your interest in my weight loss methods and hunger-controlling cookies, I find it a bit odd that one would undertake to "review" a product that he admits he has never tried. As for your opinions that one would feel hungry; that 800 calories is dangerous; and that the cookies are not appropriate for men, you don't explain why you hold these beliefs. However, I can tell you that my beliefs are those of a medical doctor who has helped more than 500,000 of his patients lose weight safely, quickly, and without hunger. Although it's little more than a year old, CookieDiet.com now has 59,000 registered users and is adding thousands more each month. We must be doing something right! Sanford Siegal, D.O., M.D. CookieDiet.com Miami, FL Thank you for taking the time to blog about Dr. Siegal’s COOKIE DIET, James. While I appreciate your interest in my weight loss methods and hunger-controlling cookies, I find it a bit odd that one would undertake to “review” a product that he admits he has never tried. As for your opinions that one would feel hungry; that 800 calories is dangerous; and that the cookies are not appropriate for men, you don’t explain why you hold these beliefs. However, I can tell you that my beliefs are those of a medical doctor who has helped more than 500,000 of his patients lose weight safely, quickly, and without hunger. Although it’s little more than a year old, CookieDiet.com now has 59,000 registered users and is adding thousands more each month. We must be doing something right!

Sanford Siegal, D.O., M.D.
CookieDiet.com
Miami, FL

]]>